A very
useful book that I have referred to in the past is Leigh Brahnam’s book, “The
7 Hidden Reasons Employees Leave.” In it Leigh describes these levels as:
1. The job or workplace was not as
expected
2. Mismatch between job and the person
3. Too little coaching and feedback
4. Too few growth and advancement
opportunities
5. Feeling devalued and unrecognized
6. Stress from overwork and work-life
imbalance
7. Loss of trust and confidence in senior
leaders
In
relation to McChrystal, I can see where #1, #3, #5, #6, and #7 may have played
a role in prompting a decorated General to proceed as he did and air his
concerns over the approach in
Even though we are talking about life and death (and politics) the situation is
really not that different from corporate scenarios. When Vice Presidents
disagree with the direction a CEO is taking a company, challenges in ideology
can emerge. It’s not uncommon for executives to boil over and make inflammatory
comments, inappropriate or insubordinate, and create a stir in the leadership
chain. As a leader dealing with publicly aired disapprovals, the choices are
straightforward – either you fire the person outright, or you reflect on why
this reaction and behavior is occurring and seek to understand the root cause.
Obama is facing that choice. He has to reconcile with an employee who has
become disengaged based on decisions made from the top and the philosophy that
followed. While the comments themselves were not as bad as they could have
been, given the circumstances and worldwide visibility and impact, the comments
should not have been shared outside the inner circle – let alone a reporter for
a pop culture magazine.
What should Obama do? Should he take a hard line and not tolerate any
insubordination or weakness in policy by firing McChrystal or from an employee
engagement perspective should he make a first stance about is expectations of
the role and rebuild trust so that McChrystal can go back in the field
re-energized and productive?
In my opinion McChrystal shouldn’t be fired because I think it will create
repercussions down to the folks in the trenches which can only result in more
casualties. McChrystal may resign on his own accord amidst the differences, but
I’m not sure what that would serve either. Obama has a chance to show real
leadership and address dissension in his ranks. I hope that an understanding
can be made and everyone can re-engage and drive to solve the issues in
Video updates here: Yahoo Video




